Summary

What if saving a human life could itself raise serious moral questions?

Millions of human embryos are estimated to be frozen in the United States, many abandoned by the parents who created them through IVF. For some, the solution seems obvious: Why not adopt these embryos, give them a chance to be born, and welcome them into loving families?

Does Catholic teaching support embryo adoption, or prohibit it? And if frozen embryos are human beings who deserve to be gestated, is leaving them frozen indefinitely morally comparable to abortion?

These questions are deeply contested within Catholic bioethics. In Part 3 of our series examining the arguments for and against embryo adoption, we turn to the case in favor of prenatal adoption and one Catholic bioethicist’s interpretation of the Vatican documents.

My guest is Dr. Elizabeth Rex, Founder and President of the Donum Vitae Institute and Associate Scholar at the Charlotte Lozier Institute. A Catholic bioethicist with a doctorate in Thomistic ethics, Dr. Rex argues that prenatal adoption can be a morally permissible response to the IVF crisis, giving frozen human embryos the opportunity to be gestated and welcomed into loving families.

Drawing on her interpretation of Donum Vitae and Dignitas Personae, Dr. Rex argues that these children deserve a chance at life. She offers a distinctive interpretation of Dignitas Personae, contending that its concerns about donor embryos and three-parent embryos should not be understood as a condemnation of prenatal adoption. She also challenges the argument that prenatal adoption is a form of surrogacy.

We discuss:

  • Why Dr. Rex believes frozen embryos are children, not property
  • Whether continued cryopreservation is morally acceptable
  • How Dr. Rex interprets Dignitas Personae and its discussion of three-parent embryos
  • Why she believes Vatican documents do not condemn prenatal adoption
  • Whether embryo adoption is an act of mercy or a form of surrogacy
  • The Catholic moral arguments surrounding embryo transfer and implantation
  • Why Dr. Rex believes frozen embryos deserve the opportunity to be gestated
  • How IVF regulation could protect embryos from destruction, genetic selection, and commercialization
  • What should happen to frozen embryos who have died
  • How Catholics can navigate the ongoing debate over prenatal adoption and human dignity

Can prenatal adoption offer frozen embryos a chance at life without crossing a moral line? What is the strongest Catholic argument in its favor, and how does Dr. Rex interpret Church teaching to support her position?

Episode Outline

00:00:00 Unpacking the Moral Dilemma of Frozen Embryos

00:02:09 Dr. Elizabeth Rex’s Path to Embryo Adoption Advocacy

00:18:17 Clarifying Terminology: Prenatal Adoption and Embryo Transfer

00:24:57 Decoding Dignitas Personae 19: The Core Embryo Debate

00:44:23 Understanding “Cannot Be Resolved” in Embryo Adoption Debate

00:59:24 Embryo Transfer as a Licit Therapeutic Medical Act

01:14:51 Catholic Church: No Condemnation of Embryo Adoption

01:29:06 How Artificial Procreation Violates the Marital Act

01:36:21 Regulating IVF and the Morality of Embryo Adoption

01:44:24 Distinguishing DP19 from Three-Parent IVF in Bioethics

01:57:08 The Duty to Rescue and Legal Status of Embryos

02:06:53 Promoting Embryo Adoption and Regulating the IVF Industry

02:19:43 Nuptial Meaning, IVF Commodification, and Ethical Regulation

02:34:54 The Fate of Unadopted Embryos and Final Moral Arguments

02:48:06 Five Key Takeaways: Catholic Case for Prenatal Adoption

About Our Guest

Elizabeth Bothamley Rex, Th.D. (cand.), Ph.D., M.B.A

President of The Donum Vitae Institute; Associate Scholar with The Charlotte Lozier Institute; and Catholic Bioethicist

Available On

Our podcast is available on the following platforms:

Apple

Spotify

YouTube

Amazon/Audible

iHeart

RSS

Share This Podcast, Choose Your Platform!

embryo adoption, prenatal adoption, Catholic bioethics, frozen embryos, frozen embryo adoption, Dr. Elizabeth Rex, Donum Vitae, Dignitas Personae, Catholic Church embryo adoption, theological case for embryo adoption, IVF ethics, human embryo dignity, Catholic moral theology, Vatican documents, embryo transfer, cryopreservation, three-parent embryos, bioethics, human dignity, sanctity of life